On opposite ends of the cancel exams debate; activist Jibran Nasir and Federal Education Minister Shafqat Mahmood have engaged in a social media war; against one another with the end result of Mahmood blocking Nasir on Twitter.
Mahmood, who had probably had enough of Nasir calling him out; decided it was time to block him. However, the news didn’t sit well with the activist who announced that despite making no personal remarks; the minister chose to block him out for the legitimate concerns he was raising.
“Seems like Shafqat Mahmood wants to live in his bubble; where he is always right and doesn’t want anyone bursting it with truth about his performance. I didn’t abuse or made any personal remark; he blocked me for only raising students concerns and demanding resignation,” he posted.
The background
Amid a surge in coronavirus cases and deaths; Mahmood announced on April 27 that O and A level exams had postponed till Oct-Nov with the only exception being A2 students “who have a compulsion to take [the] exam now”.
However, when the exams went ahead on Monday several videos emerged on social media showing a large number of parents gathered outside exam centres and a large number of students inside examination halls and it concluded that few SOPs followed and student lives were in danger.
As petitions filed against the government for approving in person exams it revealed that Pakistani students no longer had the option of switching to school assessed grades because unlike the rest of the world. Pakistan waited to postpone the exams after they had already begun.
The mess
In a series of tweets, Nasir called out the minister for his “incompetence”; determined to safeguard the lives of thousands of students.
He called Mahmood “careless” and said he was causing students stress due to his “shortsighted ill-informed policies.”
He also pointed out how schools in Pakistan were stepping up to do the job the education minister should have done a while ago; calling it “filling shoes of the government as the minister remains absent.”
A very promising message by CEO #CedarCollege Karachi informing students that schools in the city are uniting for a joint effort to get #SchoolAssessedGrades option for students. May this become a nationwide effort. Schools are filling shoes of Govt as Edu Minister remains absent pic.twitter.com/WY6Pm7IsYI
— M. Jibran Nasir (@MJibranNasir) April 29, 2021
Nasir reminded students how they weren’t given the option to get school assessed grades for their Cambridge examinations since Mahmood; despite been given a choice by the British Council; refused to cancel examinations like other countries did, putting students under unnecessary pressure.
He then made sure to reiterate that the burden of fighting for these school assessed grades wasn’t on the schools, but on the minister himself; who “ran away from the pressure by giving a half baked solution which has created this mess.”
Cheap publicity
In the midst of all this, Mahmood had said that activists were jumping in on the cause for “cheap publicity,” calling the pictures of cramped examination halls fake.
Some nobodies who have jumped into this situation for cheap publicity are going so far as to distribute fake pictures of examination halls. Their attempt to spread confusion has failed and will continue to fail because they not interested in students but self projection
— Shafqat Mahmood (@Shafqat_Mahmood) April 26, 2021
“Some nobodies who have jumped into this situation for cheap publicity are going so far as to distribute fake pictures of examination halls. Their attempt to spread confusion has failed and will continue to fail because they not interested in students but self projection,” he had said.
However, students then confirmed that the pictures were indeed a horrifying reality as they gave their examinations in terrible conditions.
Mahmood blocked Jibran Nasir
The end result? Mahmood blocked Nasir on social media. While everyone has the right to cut off anyone who takes a toll on their mental health; I guess we now know the issue had become personal.